Thursday, February 21, 2019

Week 4 Analysis: Old Monterey

Nostalgia is defined as a sentimental longing or wistful affection for the past (Dictionary.com). That is precisely the feeling that you get when you read the short story "Old Monterey". It's a story that starts off with waves crashing on the beach and an almost light-hearted and nostalgic feeling about it. What is really interesting is that the nostalgia hits from almost two angles. One angle is about how it is more of a historical nostalgia, he talks about how he could've imagined how troops met and mingled and fishermen mending their nets in the sun. This is totally nostalgic of history and its almost fascinating on how the reader feels like they are feeling reminiscent of history like they've been there before. On the other angle, the nostalgia reaches me personally. As a child, I've had memories of walking on the Monterey beach during the sunset and playing in the sand with my little brother. I find it amazing how the author was able to create two different senses of nostalgia, and when you read the story you start to feel a smile forming and its because the author makes you feel warm and fuzzy while you read. The setting of the story is honestly one of my favorite settings because personally I love the beach. The setting captivates the audience and gives the imagery of a smooth sandy beach with calm waves rolling and crashing on the sand with a thin fog flowing over the water moving inland. This setting really heightens the theme of nostalgia through the story. The historical aspect is also crazy because it fits in with the theme as well. It talks about the Mexican troops mingling and the fading of the old, old Spain and also the pursuit of treasure. The pursuit of treasure is incredible because it's basically talking about the gold rush where people were leaving everything in hopes to become insanely rich by mining gold.

6 comments:

  1. Hey Austin!

    I definitely get the theme you felt through this reading and I like how you opened your notes with the definition of nostalgia. I too am at home at the beach -- or at least I used to be! So I totally get how you can feel two different nostalgic connections (history and person) to the reading.
    I didn't get a whole lot of information on what the actual story was about though.

    Your writing is enjoyable to read, thank you for sharing!
    Amanda

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Austin,
    Defining nostalgia to better explain your thought on the theme in “Old Monterey” was very well-thought out. I like that you explained two forms of nostalgia connects, historical and personal – it provides depths to your understanding of the reading. I do feel that within the story, nostalgia drifts from moment to moment and it gives this feeling of affectionate for the past.

    Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Austin!
    I really enjoyed reading this analysis and how you defined and described nostalgia. this was not a reading that I enjoyed very much and did not get from it all of the feelings you did, but after reading your post, I am going to go back and read it with a different perspective.
    Nothing is better than reading a passage and really being able to relate to it on a personal level. I love how you were able to do this and shared your memories with us. This is a great post. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Austin, I enjoyed reading your analysis on "Old Monterey." I like how you wrote about the two angles that you noticed regarding nostalgia. I did not notice that, I guess I did not get that deep into this poem. It is great that this poem brought you back to a happy time in your childhood. This story for me seemed kind of sad. I pictured it a lonely cold beach with not many people on it for some reason. I guess I would have liked more detail on the people on this beach. Thanks for sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Austin, your analysis of Old Monterey is very informative, and you start off with a great hook to catch a readers attention and get them to start thinking. Adding a personal connection in that relates to the story is a great analyzing tool. I as well love the beach, and would like to live by one some day.

    ReplyDelete