“Our
nation is built upon a history of immigration, dating back to our first pioneers,
the Pilgrims. For more than three centuries, we have welcomed generations of
immigrants to our melting pot of hyphenated America: British-Americans; Italian-Americans;
Irish-Americans; Jewish-Americans; Mexican-Americans; Chinese-Americans; Indian-Americans”
(Ami Bera). This shows the diversity that makes up Americans and the people
wanted to seek better opportunities here. Throughout this paper I will talk
about how this work reflects history’s social, political and economic context.
When it comes to history there is nothing better than a primary source and the four
different stories from the Chinese immigrants are the greatest examples of the
hardships that they had to go through to experience a so-called better life in
America during the Gold Rush.
First
up, the social aspect of history that these immigrants had to go through. They
faced a ton of social hardships for how hard they worked. A lot of Chinese immigrants
moved to the U.S. during the gold rush in hopes of becoming incredibly wealthy.
However, they didn’t receive the warmest welcome, they faced racism, robberies
and murders while trying to make a living mining. According to an article written
by PBS a Yankee miner said, “Chinamen are getting to be altogether too
plentiful in the country” (pbs.org). This shows that there were many negative
thoughts about how the Americans welcomed the immigrants. Instead of greeting
them with open arms, the Americans shunned them for being a different race and
how they talked and certain mannerisms that they would consider weird but to the
immigrants it was their culture. The same article states “In May 1852 the state
imposed a Foreign Miners Tax, the second such tax on non-Americans in two years.
This time, a levy of $3 per month was explicitly directed at the Chinese
miners. And, as predicted, violence increased” it was also stated that “200 Chinese
miners had been robbed and four murdered at Rich Gulch” (pbs.org). They went
through all this struggle to come to America to become social pariahs. It’s
crazy to see how they were specifically targeted because they were different than
the others. Socially, these Immigrants were definitely not at the top of the food
chain of society. It’s almost haunting to see how we could have treated these
people so horribly. In our text book we see that four different immigrants
decided to speak out on how they were living, and one in particular shows how
he was treated horribly by his peers and, because of that, was given a terrible
outlook on life. He stated “he holds the pipe as his family fortune goes down
its hole. Look at him: Soon he will be six feet underground” (Anonymous Chinese
Immigrants, 355). This man put his entire family fortune into pursuing the
riches in the American land but quickly finds out that Americans are ruthless
and will do anything to put someone down for a profit especially a recently
emigrated minority.
Next
up is the political aspect. It’s funny, currently Americans have a problem with
the Mexican immigrants that move to this country and most are being incredibly
racist and targeting them politically to try and “preserve” American ideals.
But, look about three centuries ago, and find that the same politics ruled,
just targeting the Chinese-Americans as opposed to the Mexican-Americans nowadays.
The pbs article stated that “the court extended California law that African Americans
and Native Americans could not testify in court to include Chinese. The
reversal made it impossible to prosecute violence against Chinese immigrants”
(pbs.org). I find it crazy how that was able to be allowed to pass. It shows
the political racism that the Americans had toward these immigrants. History
has been littered with political racism in America and you would think that
would have changed but, according to recent politics, that is not the case.
They say history repeats itself and it couldn’t be any more true.
Finally,
the economic context. Within the four different poems written by the anonymous
immigrants, the different economic status was different for each one. The fourth
poem shows how they are trying to make a living and wishing others “may you
claim a mine full of gold. May wealth soothe your soul. Hosts and guest, so
gaily, raise the jade winecups” (Anonymous Chinese Immigrants, 355). This shows
that they were actually doing well for themselves despite the challenges of
immigration. They were drinking wine, which in most historical writings,
highlighted wealth and importance. So, it seems like they were economically
doing well. Even though it seems some did well, a lot didn’t as well. The pbs
article states “Chinese men moved into other occupations, including the laundry
business, domestic service and later railroad building” (pbs.org). This also
shows that they were forced to leave the gold mining and pursue other jobs. But,
because of their status as immigrants they were forced to do jobs that provided
a service to the Americans. That is not fair at all to these immigrants because
they worked hard to make a fortune but because they are not white Americans,
they are forced to work for them not with them.
Throughout
this paper I showed how the four different stories from the Chinese immigrants are
the best primary sources of what they had to go through as people who tried to
seek a better life. I also talked about the history of racism and hardships
that came with the immigration. I believe that the Gold Rush was not as great as
it seems because it harmed many people of a different race but then again, that
has been the theme throughout all of American history for all races.
Works
Cited
“Chinese Immigrants and the
Gold Rush.” PBS, Public Broadcasting Service,
www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/goldrush-chinese-immigrants/.
Hicks, Jack, and James D.
Houston. The Literature of California. University of California Press,
2000.
Austin,
ReplyDeleteVery interesting project and post. I only wish that America would live up to its promise as a welcoming haven for immigrants. History has shown that we have not. Anytime Americans feel that immigrants are going to take their jobs their answer is to get rid of them either legally or by extraordinary means. As you mentioned, they did this to the Chinese, finally culminating in the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882; the first law that discriminated against a named race in United States History. And, as you point out, we are presently doing the same thing to or Hispanic brothers and sisters; a terrible legacy.
Hi Austin,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed all of the information your project shares. You do very well incorporating quotes from the anonymous Chinese Immigrants. I do, however, always suggest against opening an essay or paper with the quote of another person. BUT, if you do choose to open with a quote, be sure to include that information within your Works Cited information. Also, within your Works Cited information, be sure to include a page range when referencing a portion of a collaborative book. Finally, be sure to proof read through your final submission. I am guilty of this as well, I start one thought then complete the sentence off another and leave extra words or words that don't make sense in the middle of the sentence.
Otherwise, you have a great project in the works here!
Hello Austin, Overall I think you have done a good job on your project. You have some really strong points in your writing and you back up the quotes with well thought out analysis. A suggestion I can make is to form a stronger introduction paragraph. I would say to not use a quote in your introduction but rather use that paragraph to set up and explain what it is you are going to write about. The use of different resources in your writing definitely makes a stronger argument and I think you have done a good on doing. Good luck on the rest of our project I think you are off to a good start.
ReplyDeleteHello Austin, I think you have done a very good job on your project number two. I can definitely see you put time and effort into this by the length of your project and the thoughts and ideas you described. your thesis was also very clear to read and understand, and you did a good job using quotes and ideas throughout your project to back your thesis up. This project helped me understand this story more clearly as well as see someone elses point of view. Good job.
ReplyDeleteHi Austin. What if you leave out the part in the introduction where you elaborated what you will write on? You started off strong on the introduction, but I just think that it is unnecessary to elaborate on what you will write on because that is what the thesis is for. You did a great job on the second paragraph. You used relevant quotes and did a great job analyzing them. You did a great job in your third paragraph. It is a shame that there is still racism in politics today. You did a great job informing us with this information and analyzing. It is sad and interesting at the same time that Chinese immigrants where targeted back in the days, similar to how Mexican immigrants are being targeted now in America. I noticed that you used four different sources for this project, and you did a great job organizing them in your project. What if in your conclusion paragraph you don't summarize your project? What if you use The Writing Center to help with that? Overall you did a great job and informed me well on these readings. Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteHello I think that your project was well we're doing and there are some points that are made that I agree with. To be honest I think that America has its own ways about going about things. I feel as if that when it comes to immigrants we don't really have a full grasp on how to handle these kinds of situations so when things start to go wrong in America especially with jobs or housing the immigrants always get the short end of the stick. Hopefully one day we will all come to a solution to help immigrant.But overall I think that is a good topic to talk about because not a lot of people do because it's very touchy and some ways.
ReplyDelete